Interesting Angle!

This isn’t the first time I ran into this story, and most probably same will be the case with you too. Every time I read this one till now, the answer was missing. So, I made up my own answers, a different one each time. And, I always wondered who creates such instances, if only they were to be ‘hypothetical’.

Well, I received this as a forward, again! And, it has an answer from the person who created this ‘what if’ case. May be right, may be not. It’s an interesting angle though!

 Group of children were playing near two railway tracks, one still in use while the other disused. Only one child played on the disused track, the rest on the operational track. The train came, and you were just beside the track interchange. You could make the train change its course to the disused track and saved most of the kids.

However, that would also mean the lone child playing by the disused track would be sacrificed. Or would you rather let the train go its way?

Take a pause to think what kind of decision we could make?

Most people might choose to divert the course of the train, and sacrifice only one child. You might think the same way, I guess. Exactly, I thought the same way initially because to save most of the children at the expense of only one child was rational decision most people would make, morally and emotionally. But, have you ever thought that the child choosing to play on the disused track had in fact made the right decision to play at a safe place?

Nevertheless, he had to be sacrificed because of his ignorant friends who chose to play where the danger was. This kind of dilemma happens around us everyday. In the office, community, in politics and especially in a democratic society, the minority is often sacrificed for the interest of the majority, no matter how foolish or ignorant the majority are, and how farsighted and knowledgeable the minority are. The child who chose not to play with the rest on the operational track was sidelined. And in the case he was sacrificed, no one would shed a tear for him.

The great critic Leo Velski Julian who told the story said he would not try to change the course of the train because he believed that the kids playing on the operational track should have known very well that track was still in use, and that they should have run away if they heard the train’s sirens. If the train was diverted, that lone child would definitely die because he never thought the train could come over to that track! Moreover, that track was not in use probably because it was not safe. If the train was diverted to the track, we could put the lives of all passengers on board at stake! And in your attempt to save a few kids by sacrificing one child, you might end up sacrificing hundreds of people to save these few kids. While we are all aware that life is full of tough decisions that need to be made, we may not realize that hasty decisions may not always be the right one.

“Remember that what’s right isn’t always popular… and what’s popular isn’t always right.” Everybody makes mistakes; that’s why they put erasers on pencils.

2 Replies to “Interesting Angle!”

  1. I heard about this short story since childhood and spared no time to answer this question because of lack of information about the speed of the train, distance between the track interchange and distance between me and the group of kids.

    “Sometimes in my dreams i felt like being one of the tollywood hero who can make things possible(guess people can understand whom am talking about) ”

    I feel this question is projected to < 10th grade studs to make them think(Brainstorming) to make them understand the value of singular and plural co-ordinated with life in them. Tuitors might not know the answer for this query but the person who created this brainstorming query might know whom he might have targeted to answer this query.

    "Queries Change according to the education level and the Knowledge gained through subject"

    Thanks for making me stand again on the same track and Vivee… I have a small query if you can help me with.

    Simplification of the same story

    What if you were between the disused track and active track?? Will you choose to save one or group? provided all of them are blind and def children.

    Regards,
    Bharath

    Note: Am not providing the speed and distance of the train.

    1. Hey- Very sorry for the delay. Somehow this comment skipped my radar.

      Reg. your question, am frankly not sure. I guess it’s the impulse at the time. I don’t think it’s possible for us to be prapared for all situations. In that case everything around should just be incidents and no accidents! But, we know it’s not the case.

Add a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.